• Great Day Farms Eggs
  • Sandwich bread
  • Butter
  • salt and pepper
  • shredded cheese
  • cooking spray
  • teaspoon with a pointy tip or a regular, rounded teaspoon with a butter knife


  • Using a pointy-tipped teaspoon (or a butter knife), create the corners of the edges for the rectangle on your bread, pressing almost to the crust edges. Press down to create the rectangle.
  • Using the teaspoon, gently press the bread down to form the inside of the rectangle without tearing.
  • Repeat for every slice of bread you wish to make (1-2 slices per person).
  • Season the bread with salt and pepper.
  • Crack one egg into each slice of bread prepared; season the egg on top.
  • Butter the edges of the bread gently, being careful not to touch the egg.
  • Sprinkle shredded cheese onto the butter.
  • Spray your small baking tray or tin foil with cooking spray before placing into the toaster oven. (If you don’t have a toaster oven, you can place it into a covered saute pan and cook on medium until cooked).
  • Toast in your toaster oven (or covered saute pan), observing as it cooks, until the egg appears fried, about 10 or so minutes.
  • Eat with fork and knife or as you would a piece of regular toast.


To prepare this Cheesy Baked Egg Toast in bulk, check out our Sheet Pan Cheesy Baked Egg Toast recipe!

Round Steak & Gravy

Sunny No-Bake Lemon Icebox Cake